Siemens GS54NAW42 vs Siemens GS58NAW30
Compare All Freezers
Top Prices Reasons For Date Released Key Features Energy Efficiency Price Trend Specification
Share on

Siemens GS54NAW42vsSiemens GS58NAW30

Siemens GS54NAW42

71

Overall Score

71

Overall Score
Our Verdict:
A very economical to run and phenomenally high freezer net capacity upright freezer, with good features
79
Features
Good Features
87
Running Costs
$370 Over 10 Years
71
Overall Score
Very Good
323L Upright 700mm 1,760mm Apr 2016 A+++
Freezer Net Capacity Type Width Height Release Date Energy Efficiency
Freezer Net Capacity 323L
Type Upright
Width 700mm
Height 1,760mm
Release Date Apr 2016
Energy Efficiency A+++
Siemens GS58NAW30

68

Overall Score

68

Overall Score
Our Verdict:
A good spec and extremely high freezer net capacity upright freezer, with OK running costs
79
Features
Good Features
67
Running Costs
$600 Over 10 Years
68
Overall Score
Good
360L Upright 700mm 1,910mm Sep 2012 A++
Freezer Net Capacity Type Width Height Release Date Energy Efficiency
Freezer Net Capacity 360L
Type Upright
Width 700mm
Height 1,910mm
Release Date Sep 2012
Energy Efficiency A++
Siemens GS54NAW42

71

Overall Score

71

Overall Score
Our Verdict:
A very economical to run and phenomenally high freezer net capacity upright freezer, with good features
79
Features
Good Features
87
Running Costs
$370 Over 10 Years
71
Overall Score
Very Good
323L Upright 700mm 1,760mm Apr 2016 A+++
Freezer Net Capacity Type Width Height Release Date Energy Efficiency
Freezer Net Capacity 323L
Type Upright
Width 700mm
Height 1,760mm
Release Date Apr 2016
Energy Efficiency A+++
Siemens GS58NAW30

68

Overall Score

68

Overall Score
Our Verdict:
A good spec and extremely high freezer net capacity upright freezer, with OK running costs
79
Features
Good Features
67
Running Costs
$600 Over 10 Years
68
Overall Score
Good
360L Upright 700mm 1,910mm Sep 2012 A++
Freezer Net Capacity Type Width Height Release Date Energy Efficiency
Freezer Net Capacity 360L
Type Upright
Width 700mm
Height 1,910mm
Release Date Sep 2012
Energy Efficiency A++

Top Prices

Siemens GS54NAW42 Siemens GS58NAW30
No prices found No prices found
Report an incorrect price | Found it cheaper elsewhere?

Reasons For

Siemens GS54NAW42 Siemens GS58NAW30
3 Reasons For
1dB Lower Noise Level
The Siemens GS54NAW42 has a noise level of 41dB, whereas the Siemens GS58NAW30 is a 42dB noise level freezer (1dB higher).

This is the noise level of the freezer, measured in decibels (dB).

Fewer dB means a quieter freezer, which means it is less likely to be distracting or annoying as it hums along in the background.

Read more Read less | Edit
Cheaper to Run by $226 Over Five Years
Over five years the Siemens GS54NAW42 only costs $370 to run however the Siemens GS58NAW30 costs $595 to run (61% more).
Read more Read less
Energy Efficiency Rating is Superior
The Siemens GS54NAW42 has an energy efficiency rating of "A+++", whereas the Siemens GS58NAW30 has a rating of "A++".
2 Reasons For
37L Higher Freezer Net Capacity
The Siemens GS58NAW30 is a 360L capacity freezer, whereas the Siemens GS54NAW42 is only a 323L capacity freezer (37L lower).

This is the total usable (net) capacity of the freezer, measured in litres.

A higher capacity means that more food can be stored in the freezer at a time.

Read more Read less | Edit
Eight Shelves/baskets
The number of shelves/baskets on the Siemens GS58NAW30 is eight, but the Siemens GS54NAW42 only has seven shelves/baskets.

This denotes the amount of shelves and/or baskets in the freezer.

More shelves means more space to store and organise food in your freezer, which is helpful.

Read more Read less | Edit

Date Released

Siemens GS54NAW42 Siemens GS58NAW30
22 months old Best 66 months old

Key Features

Freezer Net Capacity

This is the total usable (net) capacity of the freezer, measured in litres.

A higher capacity means that more food can be stored in the freezer at a time.

Noise Level

This is the noise level of the freezer, measured in decibels (dB).

Fewer dB means a quieter freezer, which means it is less likely to be distracting or annoying as it hums along in the background.

Shelf/basket

This denotes the amount of shelves and/or baskets in the freezer.

More shelves means more space to store and organise food in your freezer, which is helpful.

Height

Energy Efficiency

Energy Efficiency Class

Siemens GS54NAW42 Siemens GS58NAW30

Running Costs Over 10 Years

Freezer running costs calculated based on an average of 24 hours of use per day. The running cost comprises the electricity cost when using the freezer and the electricity standby cost. Compare all energy saving freezers.

Environmental Impact

We have calculated the amount of CO2 that will be generated by running each of these freezers for 10 years. We have then converted that into the number of tree seedlings that you would need to plant and grow for 10 years in order to offset that amount of CO2.
Siemens GS54NAW42
Siemens
GS54NAW42
56 trees 2.2 tonnes CO2 (Best)
Siemens GS58NAW30
Siemens
GS58NAW30
90 trees 3.5 tonnes CO2

Specification

 
 
 
Performance Siemens GS54NAW42 Siemens GS58NAW30
Freezer Net Capacity 323L 360L
BEST
Noise Level 41dB
BEST
42dB
Storage Time During Power Failure 25h 25h
Freezing Capacity 22kg/24h 22kg/24h
Freezer Gross Capacity Unknown - Click to provide data 400L
Number of Ice Packs Unknown - Click to provide data
 
 
 
Design Siemens GS54NAW42 Siemens GS58NAW30
Shelf/basket 7 8
BEST
 
 
 
Ergonomics Siemens GS54NAW42 Siemens GS58NAW30
Cord Length 2.3m 2.3m
 
 
 
Power Siemens GS54NAW42 Siemens GS58NAW30
Energy Efficiency Class
A+++ A++
 A+++
 A++
A+++ A++
 A+++
 A++
Annual Energy Consumption 187kWh
BEST
301kWh
Current 10A 10A
Connected Load 120W
BEST
90W
 
 
 
Weight & Dimensions Siemens GS54NAW42 Siemens GS58NAW30
Width 700mm 700mm
Height 1,760mm 1,910mm
Depth 780mm 780mm
Weight 88kg 107kg
BEST
Depth With Door Open Unknown - Click to provide data 1,420mm

Other Similar Comparisons

Siemens GS54NAW42
Siemens
GS54NAW42
$0.00
51% cheaper to run over five years
Energy efficiency rating is better
No Frost system
VS
Frigidaire FFFC22M6QW
Frigidaire
FFFC22M6QW
$769.00
Better brand
289L higher
freezer net
capacity
Siemens GS54NAW42
Siemens
GS54NAW42
$0.00
Better brand
63% higher freezer net capacity
Energy efficiency rating is superior
Two more shelves/baskets
3h longer storage time during power failure
Larger freezing capacity
VS
AEG ABE81226NC
AEG
ABE81226NC
$1,094.51
6% lower noise
level
Cheaper to run
by $8 over five
years
Siemens GS54NAW42
Siemens
GS54NAW42
$0.00
Higher energy efficiency rating
Seven shelves/baskets
86L higher freezer net capacity
$90 cheaper to run over five years
A little larger freezing capacity
3% lower noise level
Built-in display
Reversible doors
VS
Neff GS7343I30
Neff
GS7343I30
$1,098.99
Better brand
Siemens GS54NAW42
Siemens
GS54NAW42
$0.00
Seven shelves/baskets
12% higher freezer net capacity
VS
Siemens GS51NFW40
Siemens
GS51NFW40
$1,100.22
$25 cheaper to
run over five
years
Siemens GS54NAW42
Siemens
GS54NAW42
$0.00
$27 cheaper to run over five years
VS
Siemens GS58NAW41
Siemens
GS58NAW41
$1,208.00
37L higher
freezer net
capacity
Siemens GS54NAW42
Siemens
GS54NAW42
$0.00
86L higher freezer net capacity
Slightly larger freezing capacity
VS
Siemens GS36NAW40
Siemens
GS36NAW40
$1,330.38
$59 cheaper to
run over five
years
Marginally
lower noise
level
Siemens GS54NAW42
Siemens
GS54NAW42
$0.00
Two more shelves/baskets
Higher freezer net capacity
10% larger freezing capacity
VS
Siemens GS36NAI40
Siemens
GS36NAI40
$1,433.65
17% cheaper to
run over five
years
Slightly lower
noise level
Siemens GS58NAW30
Siemens
GS58NAW30
$0.00
Cheaper to run by $33 over five years
VS
Frigidaire FFVU17F4QW
Frigidaire
FFVU17F4QW
$758.10
Higher freezer
net capacity
Siemens GS58NAW30
Siemens
GS58NAW30
$0.00
Energy efficiency rating is better
21% cheaper to run over five years
No Frost system
VS
Frigidaire FFFC22M6QW
Frigidaire
FFFC22M6QW
$769.00
42% higher
freezer net
capacity
Siemens GS58NAW30
Siemens
GS58NAW30
$0.00
Larger freezer gross capacity
Higher freezer net capacity
Two more shelves/baskets
10% larger freezing capacity
Defrost function
Built-in display
VS
Bosch GSN36AW31
Bosch
GSN36AW31
$953.15
Better brand
22% cheaper to
run over five
years
Siemens GS58NAW30
Siemens
GS58NAW30
$0.00
Larger freezer gross capacity
Higher freezer net capacity
One more shelf/basket
10% larger freezing capacity
Defrost function
VS
Siemens GS36NAW31
Siemens
GS36NAW31
$982.34
22% cheaper to
run over five
years
Siemens GS58NAW30
Siemens
GS58NAW30
$0.00
Better brand
Higher freezer net capacity
Three more shelves/baskets
12% longer storage time during power failure
10% larger freezing capacity
VS
AEG ABE81226NC
AEG
ABE81226NC
$1,094.51
39% cheaper to
run over five
years
3dB lower noise
level
Siemens GS58NAW30
Siemens
GS58NAW30
$0.00
Three more shelves/baskets
37% larger freezer gross capacity
35% higher freezer net capacity
Larger freezing capacity
Built-in display
Reversible doors
VS
Neff GS7343I30
Neff
GS7343I30
$1,098.99
Better brand
Cheaper to run
by $128 over
five years